Banner image for Selby Jennings

Overall employee rating

2.8
Based on 22 reviews
Rating distribution: 0 reviews rated 5 out of 5 stars. 0 reviews rated 4 out of 5 stars. 7 reviews rated 3 out of 5 stars. 15 reviews rated 2 out of 5 stars. 0 reviews rated 1 out of 5 stars.
5
4
3
2
1
Detail Ratings
Work life balance
2.0
Career Growth
4.0
Work flexibility
2.0
Job Security
3.0
Pay and benefits
3.0
Leadership
3.0
Company Culture
3.0
Disclaimer: Reviews on Jobstore are independently submitted by users; we do not guarantee the accuracy or truth of any individual submission. Read more
Recruitment Consultant
3.1
5 April 2026
High-Energy, Demanding Culture, Great for Learning
Pros: The company culture in the New York City office is super high-energy, which can be motivating. You're constantly learning about the financial services recruitment market. There's a real drive to succeed, and that pushes you.
Cons: It's definitely a high-pressure environment, which makes the culture pretty demanding. It can feel quite competitive and a bit cutthroat, especially for junior Recruitment Consultant roles. The intensity can be a lot to handle some days.
Advice to Management: Try to balance the competitive nature with more team support to prevent burnout. A little less pressure could go a long way for morale.
Show more
Associate Consultant
2.1
1 April 2026
Fast-paced culture, tough for new recruiters
Pros: There's solid training for new Associate Consultants. You can learn a lot about financial services recruitment quickly. The energy in the NYC office is pretty high, which some people really like.
Cons: The company culture here is super intense. As an Associate Consultant, you're expected to put in really long hours. It's a very performance-driven environment, so it can feel cutthroat.
Advice to Management: Try to support work-life balance more for your recruitment consultants. High pressure doesn't always equal high performance long-term.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
2.9
31 March 2026
Fast-Paced, Decent Pay, but Watch Your Targets
Pros: It's a solid place to learn the ropes of financial services recruitment. The training for new recruitment consultants is pretty good, and if you perform, the commission can be really decent. There's always work in the NYC market if you can find the right candidates.
Cons: Job security here really depends on your desk and hitting those tough monthly targets. You feel the pressure constantly, especially as a recruiter. There's definitely a high turnover for some sales roles, which can be stressful.
Advice to Management: Consider more support for new hires beyond just the initial training period. High pressure is expected, but retaining good talent for recruitment consultant roles should be a priority. Maybe better retention strategies or clear paths for consistent performers.
Show more

Latest jobs from Selby Jennings

More jobs
Recruitment Consultant
2.9
1 March 2026
Expect long hours, but good career growth
Pros: As a Recruitment Consultant in the London office, I've learned a lot about financial services recruitment. The earning potential is definitely there if you hit your targets. The team environment can be pretty solid, you get to work with some driven people.
Cons: Work-life balance here is tough; you're often working well past 6 PM. It's hard to disconnect with high expectations and constant client communication. Don't expect much work flexibility, especially in your first few years.
Advice to Management: Management should really try to encourage better boundaries and perhaps implement more realistic targets. It's tough to retain good talent when everyone feels burnt out.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
3.0
18 January 2026
Pay is solid, but benefits could improve.
Pros: As a recruitment consultant, if you're good at sales, the commission structure for financial services recruitment is pretty strong. You can definitely make decent money if you hit your targets. The uncapped earning potential is a big plus here.
Cons: The base salary isn't anything to write home about, so you're really relying on that commission. Benefits like health insurance and PTO are just okay, not competitive with other firms. There's not much flexibility on WFH either.
Advice to Management: Management should seriously review the base salaries and enhance the overall benefits package. Improving health coverage and offering more WFH options would really help with retention beyond just the commission.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
3.1
4 January 2026
Hybrid Model is Okay, But Not Truly Flexible
Pros: They do offer a hybrid model for Recruitment Consultants, which is a nice perk. You get some days working from home, which helps avoid the NYC commute. It's better than being fully onsite, especially for a demanding industry like financial services recruitment.
Cons: However, the flexibility isn't really there beyond the scheduled WFH days. In-office days are mandatory and strictly enforced. If you need true remote work options or more fluid scheduling, this corporate setting won't give it to you. It's not for those seeking full work from home.
Advice to Management: Consider offering more genuine flexibility beyond the rigid hybrid schedule. Empower managers to approve ad-hoc WFH requests for specific situations. This would really help with employee morale.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
2.6
29 December 2025
Long hours are standard in finance recruiting
Pros: You learn a ton about the financial services market, especially for front office roles. The New York, NY office team is pretty supportive, which helps when things get crazy. There's good access to industry training early on.
Cons: Work-life balance here is rough, especially as a Recruitment Consultant. Expect long days, often 10-12 hours, sometimes more. It's just the nature of the recruitment industry, but it really takes a toll. Don't expect much flexibility for personal appointments.
Advice to Management: Try to recognize when teams are consistently overstretched. Maybe implement better rotation for urgent client demands, especially for junior consultants in finance recruiting. A little more support for work-life balance would go a long way.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
3.0
29 December 2025
Okay for Recruitment Consultants, But It's a Grind
Pros: You can learn a ton about financial services recruiting really fast. The commission potential is solid if you're a high-performer. There's decent flexibility with hybrid work in the NYC office too.
Cons: Work-life balance is tough as a recruitment consultant here. Expect long hours, often staying past 6 PM. The pressure to hit demanding sales targets can be pretty intense.
Advice to Management: Try to implement more realistic target setting for new consultants to help with burnout. Promote a culture where it's okay to log off on time more often.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
2.7
29 December 2025
Tough but rewarding gig in financial services recruitment
Pros: It's a good place to learn headhunting, especially for financial services recruitment. They have solid training for new Recruitment Consultants. You really learn the industry and there's clear path to earning good commission.
Cons: The work-life balance here is tough. Expect long hours, especially if you're working onsite in the NYC office. It's a demanding sales environment, which can be hard for junior talent acquisition roles. Don't expect to leave early often.
Advice to Management: Try to find ways to support better work-life balance for the team. The burnout rate can be high, especially for those in early-career talent acquisition roles.
Show more
Recruitment Consultant
2.6
28 December 2025
Fast-paced but good for sales-driven folks
Pros: You definitely get a lot of client exposure quickly as a Recruitment Consultant. The training program is pretty solid for new people in the recruitment industry. It's an energetic vibe in the New York City office.
Cons: The company culture can feel really intense, very 'work hard, play hard'. It's mostly an onsite setup, so there's not much work flexibility. Sometimes it feels like you're always competing, not collaborating.
Advice to Management: Try to foster more team collaboration. Maybe ease up a bit on the constant competition vibe.
Show more

See More Companies

Are you sure?

Once you confirm, please note that this action cannot be undone.